What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Plexaderm & More — May 19, 2026

Thirteen bottles of Plexaderm Rapid Reduction Eye Serum. That's what set the tone for this one. At $59.95 a bottle, the Plexaderm alone accounts for more than the price of the whole Amazon Mystery Box — and that was just the beginning.

The Plexaderm Haul: $779.35 Worth of Eye Serum in One Box

Thirteen units of Plexaderm Rapid Reduction Eye Serum - Advanced Formula landed in this box. If you know this brand, you know it retails hard — it's the one people talk about for under-eye bags, crow's feet, and fine lines. We pulled thirteen of them. In one box. Moving on.

Right alongside those came thirteen bottles of Bushbalm Nude Ingrown Body Hair Oil — paraben-free, non-toxic, tea tree scent, $26 each. Another $338 worth of a brand that has a real following. This box was clearly not messing around on the personal care side.

Then fifteen — yes, fifteen — Automatic Soap Dispensers from S&S Global Finds. Touchless, foaming, USB-C rechargeable, with a digital display and a genuinely sleek beige design that looks more expensive than $17. These work great for bathrooms, kitchen sinks, offices — and at that price point, they're easy gifting.

We also pulled six Mango Swirl 3 In 1 Scrubs with African Shea & Glycolic Acid from Botanic Hearth, ten Smart Bouncing Balls for Pets (those are going to be popular with the dog crowd in Hot Springs), two sets of GOTIDEAL Liquid Chalk Markers — 18-piece sets with 14 unique colors plus 4 metallics, and one bottle of Native Body Wash in Grapefruit & Bergamo to round things out.

Total estimated retail across the notable items: well over $1,500. Plus a handful of bin-labeled pieces heading straight to our store bins. All of it out of one sealed Amazon Mystery Box. These are the kinds of opens that remind us why we do this.