What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Nike & More — June 15, 2026

A Nike Dunk High 1985 Barely Rose in Size 10 was the first notable thing out of the box. At $125 retail, it's the kind of find that makes the $55 price tag feel like a cheat code. The colorway is soft — barely-there pink on a classic high-top silhouette — and the box was sealed.

The Birkenstock Women's Mayari Black Birko-Flor Was a Close Second

Right behind it: a pair of Birkenstock Women's Mayari Black Birko-Flor sandals at $79.99 retail. That's the woven toe-loop style Birkenstocks that have basically never gone out of fashion. Black Birko-Flor means they look almost like leather. Classic, clean, easy to move in our Hot Springs store.

Together those two pairs account for roughly $205 of the box's $317 estimated retail value. The rest came out as bin-labeled pieces — plus plenty more headed straight into our store bins for customers to dig through.

Not every Amazon Mystery Box hits $500+, and this one didn't try to. What it did deliver was two genuinely wearable, brand-name shoes at a combined retail that covers the cost of the box more than three times over. Solid, unpretentious, exactly what you hope for on a Sunday pull.