What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: GREENIES & More — May 26, 2026

Honestly? This one was a grower. Nothing flashy on the surface, but once we started pulling items, the value stacked up fast. Twenty-seven items worth naming, plus a handful of bin-labeled pieces heading straight into our store bins — and a few genuinely good finds tucked in with the everyday staples.

Three TriggerPoint Grid Foam Rollers at $31.89 Each? Yes Please.

That's the headliner right there. Three TriggerPoint Grid Foam Roller - Black units at nearly $32 a pop adds up to almost a hundred bucks in foam rollers alone. These sell. People in Hot Springs who work out, run, or just sit at a desk all day know what these are worth.

Right behind that, five PreserVision AREDS 2 Eye Vitamins with Lutein & Zeaxanthin Softgels - 120ct at $30.49 each. Five of them. That's over $150 in eye vitamins from a single box, which is either wild luck or the universe telling us something about screen time.

Two Greenies Weight Management Teenie Natural Dog Dental Care Chews Weight Control Dog Treats 27 Oz Pack (96 Treats) rounded out the pet section at $33 each — big bags, great value if you've got a small dog who could stand to skip a few snacks. Plus one Canine Carry Outs Hot Dog Minis Dog Treats 22.5oz Bag for good measure.

Eleven Dixie Ultra Paper Bowls 20 oz 26 count at $10.26 each is the kind of bulk find that's unglamorous but genuinely useful — those go fast. Three bags of illy Ground Espresso Coffee Intenso Bold Roast 100% Arabica 8.8 oz at $15.99 each had us briefly considering keeping them. One Melitta Natural Brown #4 Coffee Filter 100ct to go with the coffee theme. And one lone Play Doh thrown in at the end, because these Amazon Mystery Boxes always have one wild card.

All in, roughly $520 in retail value across 32 items. Solid box. Come grab what's yours.