What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Cards Against Humanity & More — May 22, 2026

Listen, not every Amazon Mystery Box is going to knock your socks off. This one came in at $202 estimated retail value across 27 total items, and honestly? It was a pretty modest haul. But sometimes a box earns its keep with just one solid find.

Four Sealed Copies of Cards Against Humanity • Main Game: Social Skills Party Game, 4+ Players, Includes Cards, 30+ Min Playtime

Yep. Four of them. Brand new, sealed, ready to ruin a perfectly respectable game night. At $21.75 each, that's not a bad haul on its own — and if you've been looking for a gift for literally anyone with a sense of humor, Hot Springs has you covered now. We've got all four on the floor.

The rest of the box was quieter. Twenty-three bin-labeled pieces headed straight to our store bins, which means plenty more to dig through if you come in person. That's the thing about our bins — you never know what's tucked in there until you look.

As Amazon Mystery Boxes go, this one was mid. But Cards Against Humanity showing up four times in a single box? That's the kind of weird little win that makes opening these things fun. We'll take it.