What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Anna & More — May 17, 2026

Look, we're not here to explain why two one-pound bags of ANNA, FUSILLI, ENRICHED MACARONI PRODUCT 1lb are retailing at $45.51 each. We're just here to tell you they were in the box. Sealed. Brand new. That's $91 worth of fusilli in a single Amazon Mystery Box that costs $55. Make it make sense — or just buy the pasta.

The Hasbro Collectibles - Marvel Avengers - Titan Hero Series - 12" Deluxe Hulk Action Figure Was the Fan Favorite

Our team pulled this one out and it got an immediate reaction. The 12-inch Deluxe Hulk retails at $22.98 and came out in perfect condition. Great gift item. The kind of thing that disappears from our shelves fast.

Rounding out the notable finds: two copies of the Classic Boggle Word Search Game For Kids Ages 8 and Up at $17.89 each — solid gift territory — plus two bottles of Ethos Car Detail Spray - The Ultimate Quick Car Detailer for Car Shine & Protection - Enhances Gloss, Slickness & Hydrophobic Properties - Detailing Spray - Safe for Paint, Glass & Chrome at $14.99 each. If you keep your car clean, those are genuinely useful. Two pouches of Tea Better Kashmiri Kahwa Traditional Blend at $9.99 each rounded things out on the more unexpected end — Kashmiri Kahwa is a spiced green tea blend, and it's lovely if you've never tried it. There was also a Clay Sculpting Kit in the mix for $9.99 retail.

Total estimated retail on the named items alone clears $200, plus dozens more bin-labeled items heading to our store bins. For a $55 box, the ratio held up — even if the pasta situation remains a mystery we'll be thinking about all week.